The Journal

MANAGEMENTS, Africa-Europe

A scientific management journal published by MDI-Algiers Business School, appearing twice a year with an average of five to six articles per issue.

Overview

Through its title, “MANAGEMENTS”, the Journal seeks to justify neither the fragmentation of managerial forms nor the impossibility of accounting for them. It simply indicates that there are different managerial landscapes, depending on the geopolitical, symbolic or cultural territories that underpin management conduct.

The Journal appears twice a year, with an average of five to six articles per issue, complementing its scientific content with methodological or practical commentaries, as well as accounts of experiences and reading recommendations.

It is also a place of exchange between researchers and practitioners: scientifically grounded research, with a critical eye combining several complementary reflexive positions, but capable of providing practical solutions or operational recommendations.

A word from the scientific director

Building a high-quality, ranked African journal

In the journal rankings drawn up by FNEGE in 2016, African journals are notably absent. The few emerging or formerly ranked journals have disappeared from the list. On analysis, the combined reasons are as follows:

  • the difficulty of organising the follow-up of these journals. The work of an editor-in-chief is very demanding. The process of collecting and reviewing article proposals requires a great deal of availability. At the same time, a reliable and diverse group of reviewers must be put together;
  • the lack of an editorial policy in these journals. Researchers cannot be motivated by geographical positioning alone; they must be made to want to publish through attractive research questions and objectives;
  • the insufficient supply of research papers. Submissions must be encouraged, networks run, and the journal built up until it reaches the reputation that will allow it to be supplied spontaneously. Until this threshold is reached (sometimes several years later), incentives and reminders are costly.

To build a high-quality, ranked journal, these problems must be solved. With MDI-Algiers Business School as publisher, we conceived a problem-driven journal, with an editorial line centred on managerial contextualisation. It will be set within African perspectives, without being limited to them, for example by fostering the Europe-Africa dialogue and the shared or specific experiences of the two continents.

It will be called MANAGEMENTS, to assert a managerial diversity that the editorial line will describe and argue for. Its subtitle, Africa-Europe, reflects a dialogue between the practices observable on either side of the Mediterranean.

This journal will differ from others in three ways:

  • through its contextual approach, it will draw on observable practices. Analytical rigour and efforts at generalisation will be required, but without separating them from managerial environments (for example types of companies, institutional frameworks or local cultures);
  • it will have a dual audience. Its texts will be primarily intended for researchers (scientific contributions), but written to be understood and used by practitioners (practical implications). It will include research articles, but also methodological texts or texts with a teaching purpose;
  • it will foster joint reflection between Africans and Europeans, following a “vertical” geopolitics, in the belief that management theories can also be built outside North American or Asian pressures. It will pay particular attention to innovations and to taking diversity into account.

Pr. Pierre LouartScientific director of the journal

Scientific rationale

“Since perception is usually highly dependent on context, the value of eliminating it seems most doubtful.”
Karl Popper
  1. 01

    The demand for managerial variety rests on institutional or cultural facts.

    But the aim is not to justify exceptions or local problems that would prevent general rules from being applied, on the pretext that these rules come up against traditions that reject them.

    In reality, supposedly universal rules are universal in relation to particular contexts. They are relative universals, linked to axiologies or ideologies that are often implicit. It is the duty of management sciences to collect interesting experiences, with partial generalisations, since they are likely to work or be reproduced in appropriate places or territories (1). Insofar as there are several types of ecosystems, and they can be defined scientifically through situational explanations, managerial forms can be identified (or tested) “in situ” and accounted for.

    At the same time, current thinking on companies encourages us to rethink them as objects of law, economics or sociology as well as objects for management sciences. This global view makes it possible to rethink the company and its management. Societal perspectives can be incorporated not only as cultural effects (or as specificities more or less degraded in relation to a European, American or Asian optimum), but as ways of managing collective action and its managerial effects according to particular legal and societal choices (2).

    To do so, let us connect with social science researchers who do not aim to absorb the theoretical models of management sciences (nor to replace them), but who engage in dialogue with them in a spirit of open complementarity.

    To take a few examples, we could draw on approaches to “the living as a model” or “frugality”, economics of conventions, sociologies of use, reflections on a creative law, or more broadly management perspectives in which the company is not a passive tool on which external rationalities are imposed, but a laboratory of experiments that are both cognitive and social.

    More and more researchers regard companies as organisations with multiple purposes, which can be evaluated according to multi-criteria results or performance.

    Let us therefore accept that there are different types of managerial choices, each with optimal (or ingenious) forms to be designed. Let us make management sciences both sciences of elucidating observable reality (starting from facts, examples and contexts) and sciences of building, repairing or restoring the health of systems (as law, engineering or medicine do in their own way).

  2. 02

    Through its title, “MANAGEMENTS”, the Journal seeks to justify neither the fragmentation of managerial forms nor the impossibility of accounting for them. It simply indicates that there are different managerial landscapes, depending on the geopolitical, symbolic or cultural territories that underpin management conduct.

    For example, it can be said that the cultural level (of education or understanding) of organisational actors has immediate effects on HRM practices. To deny this would be to refuse the obvious. Likewise, the degree of trust between actors considerably alters the need for internal regulation. The more trust there is, the more spontaneous or implicit interactions can be. The reverse is true when mistrust sets in, or when the size of the organisation makes it necessary to create formal regulations. But it can also be inferred that excessive regulation reduces spontaneous ties (it breeds mistrust), and that too large an organisational surface, by forcing formalisation, hinders the social construction of trust.

    The aim of this Journal is therefore to encourage scientific accounts of innovative experiences, or to describe context-specific managerial features, or even to create more optimal ones. We will take advantage of the fact that African soil (which is highly varied) has become a testing ground for pioneering trials of all kinds (from political regulation to international contracting, including numerous entrepreneurial emergences). It will also be possible to bring in European practices that could be transferred, or to assess the various forms taken by partnerships (business, cooperation or exchange) between Africa and Europe.

  3. 03

    The Journal will appear twice a year, with an average of five to six articles per issue, complementing its scientific content with methodological or practical commentaries, as well as accounts of experiences and reading recommendations.

    We expect the members of the scientific committee to strive to guarantee the quality of the Journal, while helping to find competent young authors who may apply for publication.

    Members of the scientific committee will, if they wish, be part of the review committee. Their suggestions of reviewers with expertise who meet their deadlines will be gratefully received. We have relied, though not exclusively, on people who know Africa (North African or sub-Saharan) and who are interested in open management.

    At the same time, the Journal will be a place of exchange between researchers and practitioners. We will welcome research that is scientifically grounded, with a critical eye combining several complementary reflexive positions, but capable of providing practical solutions or operational recommendations. Where appropriate, some research may also conclude with warnings against certain behaviours with perverse effects (unexpected and harmful to some of the actors in the processes studied).

    We will be very attentive to ensuring that a topic studied does not obscure the essential questions it faces. Management research must ask questions that can be answered, in theory, in methodology and in the concrete issues it raises. It is therefore normal for it to limit its objects of study. But the chosen scope must neither exclude facts that are essential to overall understanding, nor neglect certain causalities that are at least as valuable, in themselves, as the objects studied.

    In short, the Journal must also teach researchers from African countries to position themselves on useful questions and, in doing so, to address them rigorously. This rigour obliges them to think broadly around the questions that interest them, so as not to deny the influence of context. If necessary, they must look in the environments of what they study for the explanations they were unable to find within the field they had initially defined.

  4. 04

    To understand local managements, we would like in-depth reflection on the reference societies and on the institutional context that shapes the action of companies.

    Just as the work of François Jullien, for example, is essential for understanding collective functioning in China, and for explaining how that country’s cultural traits indirectly influence its management models, so it will be useful to go through an understanding of African practices to give meaning to what has been observed. Analysing host environments and their specificities will make it possible to find paths of change, evolution or progress suited to the sectors studied.

    For some time now, social science researchers have emphasised neo-institutional approaches, explaining that every economy is embedded in the society in which it operates. But the way this embeddedness is viewed in the United States, for example, is not the same as in Côte d’Ivoire, South Africa or Tunisia. And all of this has an impact on management.

  5. 05

    In conclusion, we want to make MANAGEMENTS a collective adventure, respecting people and the institutional, cultural or social specificities of the contexts studied. This in no way prevents the modelling of rigorous managerial approaches, in observing, explaining or evaluating ways of making things evolve.

    The scientific committee will therefore have, at the very least, a twofold mission:

    • to ensure the rigour of analyses, in order to produce high-quality scientific content;
    • to take an active part in disseminating this editorial project, whose research orientations and perspectives are specific.

    Together, we must both stimulate reviewers interested in the journal and attract authors of innovative texts that can become good articles through a dynamic review process.

P. L.

Open call

Preparing an article?
Submit it to the journal.

Guidelines and submission